[6bone] RFC2772 rewrite -- bigger scope goals
Jorgensen, Roger
RJorgensen@upctechnology.com
Sun, 17 Nov 2002 21:51:25 +0100
(someone might be offended by I'm sick of this threat now...)
> On Sun, 2002-11-17 at 16:57, Jeroen Massar wrote:
> >
> > On which _real_ IX (check http://www.v6nap.net/) is "NDSOFTWARE"
> > present?
> > Maybe you can go there and people would be pleased to setup a native
> > peering.
>
> mv troll /dev/null
IF this is how you handle critic I suggest you really stop mailing
now.I'm getting sick of your very unproductive respons to everything.
You have shown MANY times that you do not have any clue about
how REAL network work, REAL as in real routing hardware and real
links, NOT tunnels and a few BSD/linux boxes with zebra or whatever
you use.
Please stop this now. And let's ALL move back to RFC 2772 discussion.
> I have sent an email (09 Oct 2002 00:50:52 +0200) to Marc Blanchet for
> update the list of http://www.v6nap.net, but i don't get
> news. The list
> is not updated, there is a lot of other IX who have an IPv6
> support...
>
>
> > > - Many pTLA offer a real production quality service, why
> limit them ?
> >
> > If they offer production services they should move to RIR
> space as 6bone
> > space was meant for _testing_ and _experimental_ purposes.
>
> production quality service != production service
>
> > > - IPv6 world must have the same routing policy, why
> complicate IPv6
> > > routing ?
> >
> > The same as which? As IPv4? Where people inject /30's into the DFZ?
> > There was another reason for making IPv6 and limiting on TLA sizes:
> > smaller global routing tables.
> > Or at least the hope of keeping it in limits so you don't
> have to buy
> > a new router with 1TB of memory.
>
> I mean: pTLA and sTLA (IPv6 world) must have the same routing policy.
>
> I don't talk about IPv4.
>
> > > have a good routing (we use filtering, MED,...).
> > >
> > > A lot of sTLA don't operate their sTLA professionally.
> > > A lot of sTLA don't have a 24x7 contact and don't reply
> > > within 24 hours.
> > > A lot of sTLA don't have a good routing (they don't use filtering,
> > > MED,...)
> >
> > Yeah yeah you pasted that before, do you realize it stands for Multi
> > Exit Descriminator?
> > But how can you use it if you only have 1 exit or have you
> got your own
> > native IPv6 cables
> > between your routers?
>
> Learn how BGP work.
> If you have many peers, you have many exit.
>
>
>
> Network Next Hop Metric LocPrf Weight Path
> * 2001:200::/35 3ffe:8270:0:1::30
> 500 0 20834 513
> 3425 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:2a::2
> 502 0 3292 109
> 4554 2500 i
> * 2001:768:e:9::1 510 0 8379 3561
> 5511 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:d::2
> 540 0
> 17715 4725
> 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:31::2
> 520 0
> 12731 5539
> 4554 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:28::2
> 520 0
> 20794 6830
> 4554 2500 i
> * 2001:7b0:1ff::c 520 0
> 15671 8627
> 790 3549 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4005:0:1::2e
> 500 0
> 24765 1752
> 5511 2500 i
> * 2001:7a8:1:f004::1
> 500 0
> 13193 3549
> 2500 i
> *> 2001:7f8:2:c01d::2
> 500 0 1752 5511
> 2500 i
> * 3ffe:2200:0:8012::1
> 520 0 2607 6939
> 2516 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:a::2
> 520 0
> 15589 6939
> 2497 2500 i
> * 3ffe:8340::1:6 510 0
> 13129 1752
> 5511 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:29::2
> 500 0
> 8921 13193
> 3549 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:b::2
> 530 0 9112 4554
> 2500 i
> * 3ffe:400c:feed::2
> 530 0
> 13110 4554
> 2500 i
> * 3ffe:4013:f:27::2
> 520 0 8472 6830
> 4554 2500 i
>
>
> BGP choose the route(s) with shorter ASpath and lower MED.
>
> Network Next Hop Metric LocPrf Weight Path
> * 2001:7a8:1:f004::1
> 500 0
> 13193 3549
> 2500 i
> *> 2001:7f8:2:c01d::2
> 500 0 1752 5511
> 2500 i
>
> If there is many routes with the same ASpath size, BGP choose
> the route
> will the lower ASN.
>
> Network Next Hop Metric LocPrf Weight Path
> *> 2001:7f8:2:c01d::2
> 500 0 1752 5511
> 2500 i
>
>
> Best Regards,
>
> --
> Nicolas DEFFAYET, NDSoftware
> NOC Website: http://noc.ndsoftwarenet.com/
> FNIX6: http://www.fnix6.net/
>
> _______________________________________________
> 6bone mailing list
> 6bone@mailman.isi.edu
> http://mailman.isi.edu/mailman/listinfo/6bone
>
begin 600 winmail.dat
M>)\^(@D4`0:0"``$```````!``$``0>0!@`(````Y`0```````#H``$(@`<`
M&````$E032Y-:6-R;W-O9G0@36%I;"Y.;W1E`#$(`06``P`.````T@<+`!$`
M%0`S`!D```!6`0$@@`,`#@```-('"P`1`!4`.``'````20$!"8`!`"$```!!
M-#DT.4$S-T-",#$U-C0X.$)"-S)".3,U.#4X-C$U.``$!P$$@`$`,@```%)%
M.B!;-F)O;F5=(%)&0S(W-S(@<F5W<FET92`M+2!B:6=G97(@<V-O<&4@9V]A
M;',`[`\!#8`$``(````"``(``0.0!@`8$```+P````,`"(`((`8``````,``
M``````!&`````%*%``!];@$`'@`)@`@@!@``````P````````$8`````5(4`
M``$````$````.2XP``L`"H`((`8``````,````````!&``````:%````````
M`P`+@`@@!@``````P````````$8``````84````````+``"`""`&``````#`
M````````1@`````#A0````````L`%(`((`8``````,````````!&``````Z%
M`````````P`"@`@@!@``````P````````$8`````$(4````````#`!6`""`&
M``````#`````````1@`````1A0````````,`%X`((`8``````,````````!&
M`````!B%`````````@$)$`$```"G"@``HPH``*89``!,6D9U/(HV%@,`"@!R
M8W!G,3(UXC(#0W1E>`5!`0,!]_\*@`*D`^0'$P*`#_,`4`16/PA5![(1)0Y1
M`P$"`&-HX0K`<V5T,@8`!L,1)?8S!$83MS`2+!$S".\)][8[&!\.,#41(@Q@
M8P!0,PL)`60S-A90"Z8@*`IS`W!E`B!E(&UIU&=H!4!B'6!O`2`)\`4!`&0=
MT'D@22=MBB`-T6L>`2!T:`0`"Q^!&"!A!4!N;W<N'2"`*0JB"H0A!CX@3T$#
MH%-U;BP@`=`PD#(M,3$BP#<@("&@,38Z-3<B8$H$D+9O"?`%T&$$$`K!=P-@
MO0ZP.B&&(>`E&"(!=Q^@21/0(%\@`6Q?'L!8'QS@$]`%D!]`';!T<#H(+R]W
M*&`N=C9N"&%P+AU0="\I(`$?L2).1%-/1E2@5T%212(E&'`8(%L4$`(P/R48
M)$!Y'>%YR0A@(&,#D6=O'X$$D'<=8`!P'H!P'3`+4!U@=WT(8&P>@1U@+?$D
M4!YQ=',M`!01=7`C("!`("!I''9E*ED)X`40;F<NLR&&(89M=A^``V!L`R#B
M+P$`=B]N+E`8`"#9[$E&'X0?L6@@8"QC$^!O'E`N`04!,!!C'L`?`'6\9V<'
MD`5`+'(F\FP>L.\VT"W@'7`+<&PQ,2#$(%+_'M(VL`)`,3$?!RQQ!<`P,/YR
M'K`B0"KP!'`:T#`2-S'\<W`"(!_!+0`S(#JQ'Y';,4<]*EDU4SN1<S4!)"'X
M04Y9'X`'<Q^0("$L<GYD+0`@4`5`/H,`<!ZP8^<*02,@!N!U=#TD-0(J(-Q!
M3"!`%"`N,'(?0$,R_R)@0K,D4"E0`Z`F\C<P0>'S.9(3X61W"L`M9";R/22)
M.#%K<R)@3D]4'X#[(D`=4&P$("V"+]`>,`?@D$)31"\X,75X'=`<;W@'D0/P
M'Y`@>F7\8G(OT`6Q)H`@(#QR):7=+')U%!`]'PJ`4"[3-Z2?'Y,@4A#`+9$N
M`'0G$+'N3$+@!&`[D6(`T!]`+T'H4D9#(G`W`<!`8`0`_F-+L`"0`B!+[PJ`
M):<V8#\^A"LQ+7$\8#@"'.`P.?<A\#M@(G,@(I`C@%5!%$"^*R*@(I`I0"]!
M)$!R-D"Z0@M@;B>1!4`"$'(AAOTOH&1*H2T23J`$``5`'V%W)_\I`2)@8D'P
M*5!`86Z>)P5`.5$EIQU0=W-.4+Y46'4AADWS!4!7]&0B8/\M)!^Q+]`7L%C3
M)-`M,2="[R:`+0!`Y1[`4"B@):<V@'YP._``(""!):<Q?B5R+<,D,4%!<%1,
M01X#!<"/+]!$DSL6`B`@<74'0-<V$#>1!)!V#>!E(F`F@/\>L"&&.#`=@`5`
M+2$>\"MI]6CH21]R91ZP9-1EJ6;5/Q_":G$^T2Y23U-/\DE2[V$8"K!G($0B
M-@;@'5!HZ/]N1$6@!"`'@`!P5R,FT`ZP[S;0,3$G,"V"7P[`+<`%$/<'@`(P
M)Q)P"'`[\!007##',7YEKV:W("$]:O]G(/]BWV/C8--#,6S22[!`Q5ABGR1P
M!X!$USOP.#!C>6=,_06@;0M0#>!8(F#28UI$YK]HWR5R7&)Z4T0Q)H,_$,#K
M!"!@T32`\%<M,RW%"X#&:@60!4`O,S!.X0N`XR]!6&)$1EHK:5QA+5'_<"(`
M<%^$(`$=``.@<,(`P/YK.9)@TRV":",YDG3A9)+K`)!)\',E"7,`P#+0$H'^
M9Q>P3Z!$R`&1+@!S2"'A?V41!4`NTFAC-/$MP!]2:_T)X'`YDFA11&%H(P0@
M'0"_0"5;`B&&><0M`%J`>7ZH'R_1!]%$XA*!2:,Q5$)_'U('@`1@.L!S7S9@
M<&(ZZV1T+8)S9)(H>,@I0'E__WJ.DV\V8%KD<H$?0$'#@3,_F+\E<D#D+.$$
M<$37*'=_'6!+L4A0`Q"2`3$Q(F!-^$5$+"""BUEC/&2P7Q7?E8-:Y(T12B!8
M-&D%P)6#_SL1'C!1`S=BGWNA#UL1G(7X,C1X(Q`%H')Q5+$M@O]:Y!@@"U!G
MB"5R2:)$8:;0_S3Q"'"+2J4/IAJ<_&I36N3?G@QC6I[V?J\E@5D@$";`_GFQ
MTRR!"K`VT"\2/_(=X/]706<Q0'$W!HB1C?(VT"V!.P0@<,)-+E`P$+"(17C]
M:%%$!Y`%`1V`+_$%L"MI_D):D34"++)+=8WS.C.(`?LW@3Z#,3Q@MK(%L3Z#
M+'+_(88L\#;C!<`^\;"(+_1@Q/\LL(L2L(@=X$,@">$Z1)'4=G,K9R&&3"`0
M!*$U`D+\1U!#<YLW:B$U1#N1`X'_9&$Q`4<1P_R[$IL_,7[(8=\'P$,DR1<'
MP`[12#?1RCD.310@!1`V0$QO8U!:<A]P5Z+@':)0("!H32&&*LA@(H$Q.B*!
M.BDH,#,UR&(S'B$Z..]08%5`54#-8#J"\,?YS_]_T0_)%%5@%E#*.A90`=`X
M\C.IX#4Q%3`AE=/0#C"_(G#2@K7WS0'6#\Y#-,U0Z#,Z9LUP8<VP#E#/;X_9
M3]&/50'2S#,R.11`]C%4<"&&-!I@J>#5#][?H<TS-S8X.B3P.<VPW[KPTA;<
MT-*]T\`W5(#-X/XV&O,APAI@(M#=S^3?UQO^9-@/Y]_H[])2UW#2O2&&J2,`
M-S'-\#0!P#4AAO?C[^W_URHSSP'F__$?\B]_TG`<P>I_ZX108._0XX$S_]S_
M[2_N/]=8X&#P#_I_^X__\S_K*0'0XJ"IX.!0SSCV'_OW+]^I8L[A#S#-L#9`
M_%_O\__BX.OPXG`V4&`AAN*@/]QA_Z!4@/_?![_7)3`U_<[4,C!'"E\+;]'_
M`^^FP?_@0,WP(P!5D.,?!O\!+^`PSF'@8,U@''`P-."Q">^?%&\5?PT?ZTCO
MT#DS!E.O['_,M!//W]9FX&`R`L#_S5#FSQU?'F\67]-3#Q(/P[<8WQ"_^`LR
MS8)50#C-4+\<`!-/)B\G/P-/TW(V_G#W;L`88!C),6$`(?\K_]<JG]?_+M\O
M[R@_!#TU.%2`_RGK!H"G`"K_-5_.1-/0S:'_S6!A`.#O,=\8,=R0#P\T3_\[
M[]<<X*$N#S\?0"\?O_18_3,0,N#0&#/4-P9_.\\\WGYB/?](7TEO02*"\-*]
M.;\A4%"0_X(A?T3_"%YCU[#_P``<7U#?4>]*?Q=N-_%,+_=-/TY/UW8W3^]:
M#UL?,1__XD/L,?Z_5?W'?L*R@-"LX.>>$8.2D=,H<Y:`DD-LD?)RD@)!4[*@
MDF&'0[TP_V4!GO'&;\A_R8_*G\NO5I__$<\2WVS/;=]`SU//&"]5[_]LOQM?
M60]V7W=O;U\@KW(/_Y/HP]"%@KF1A3#%TY'3@('_DE*71V,5B(*>T&#)=89A
M=[]UAI)`B;"#@V/$8Q!.9%__96]F?V>/:)]RWW/O=/^+3_^,7W@O>3]Z3U]?
M8&6_`+;0>%)E9\(PM4"O-XK6+7HM@U=.AJ"88+*PMN!%0$9&05E%5)[03CQ$
M4ZN`O^#",`G73D]:0X<Q8J/0HI`ZNI!TI'1PS<`O;H;@+K4QE97E;H9P+J<@
M;2^*UJ!&3DE8-I>'=YK0P"YF;FEX-IA`AG![F6>*UE^<OYW/GIJ*UC;^8J80
MQ;*NL*UBM("U`)^KED"@@L71+GS0:2ZRX-YUBM:7I:(MH_8OH0*W8"VU<"^@
M(X+L?:=0`!X`<``!````+@```%LV8F]N95T@4D9#,C<W,B!R97=R:71E("TM
M(&)I9V=E<B!S8V]P92!G;V%L<P````(!<0`!````&P````'"CFUBS67C/%;Z
M4A'6MGX`L-!)+J$``\HKX``#`"X```````L``@`!`````P`)60$````>`$(0
M`0```#@````\,3`S-S4V,#$Q."XV,S4N-C0V,2YC86UE;$!W:W,Q+F9R+F-O
M<G`N;F1S;V9T=V%R92YC;VT^``,`WC^O;P``0``Y`,"/!AA[CL(!`P#Q/PD$
M```>`#%``0````L```!22D]21T5.4T5.```#`!I``````!X`,$`!````"P``
M`%)*3U)'14Y314X```,`&4```````P#]/^0$```#`"8```````,`-@``````
M`P"`$/____\"`4<``0```#(```!C/553.V$](#MP/4-(14Q,3SML/4Y,0T)"
M35,P,RTP,C$Q,3<R,#4Q,C5:+3@W,#`X`````@'Y/P$```!/`````````-RG
M0,C`0A`:M+D(`"LOX8(!`````````"]//4-(14Q,3R]/53U!35-415)$04TO
M0TX]4D5#25!)14Y44R]#3CU22D]21T5.4T5.```>`/@_`0```!$```!*;W)G
M96YS96XL(%)O9V5R`````!X`.$`!````"P```%)*3U)'14Y314X```(!^S\!
M````3P````````#<IT#(P$(0&K2Y"``K+^&"`0`````````O3SU#2$5,3$\O
M3U4]04U35$521$%-+T-./5)%0TE0245.5%,O0TX]4DI/4D=%3E-%3@``'@#Z
M/P$````1````2F]R9V5N<V5N+"!2;V=E<@`````>`#E``0````L```!22D]2
M1T5.4T5.``!```<PJ!7[R7J.P@%```@PNN!$P'N.P@$>`#T``0````4```!2
M13H@`````!X`'0X!````+@```%LV8F]N95T@4D9#,C<W,B!R97=R:71E("TM
M(&)I9V=E<B!S8V]P92!G;V%L<P```!X`-1`!````-0```#PW0T5!-#!#,$4Q
M,$,W1#1&0D4P-S9!13=#,T5&0C<X1#`Q,31#-3)%0&YL8V)B;7,P,SX`````
M"P`I```````+`",```````,`!A#+C_3S`P`'$#(+```#`!`0``````,`$1`!
M````'@`($`$```!E````*%-/345/3D5-24=(5$)%3T9&14Y$141"64E-4TE#
M2T]&5$A)4U1(4D5!5$Y/5RE/3E-53BPR,#`R+3$Q+3$W050Q-CHU-RQ*15)/
M14Y-05-305)74D]413I/3E=(24-(4D5!3``````"`7\``0```#4````\-T-%
M030P0S!%,3!#-T0T1D)%,#<V044W0S-%1D(W.$0P,3$T0S4R14!N;&-B8FUS
),#,^`````.!1
`
end