Toning it down. Re: [6bone] FAQ about pTLA request NDSOFTWARE - review closes 23 October 2002

[Chuck Yerkes]

Intended generally, to the participants in this discussion:

I'll happily allow that M. DEFFAYET does not use English as his
first language and suggest that highlighting slight misuses of it
is not acceptable in this review phase; instead, asking for and
dealing with the requests and information contained within the words
is appropriate.

Let's re-elevate the discussion back to a civil level without taking
language and the lack of nuance in email into it.


That said, I have a couple thoughts, first being that being a website
hosting/design company that ONLY serves IPv6 would seem a tad
premature to offer with any hope of success.

The next thought being that I too have a CoLo'd machine and one
that, until last friday, was at home on a static IP address.  A
move blew the latter situation apart.

I never felt a real need for multiple IP addresses at the Colo
machine, though it does provide tunnels and IPSec endpoints for
several people.  I've gotten on just fine with a fairly small
allocation.

I'd much rather have upstream ISPs route my once portable Class C
(24 bit is useless these days).

A pTLA never seemed justified except in the lab, where a fictional
one (blocked at the router) was used to learn a bit about some of
the capabilities of some software and hardware tools we were playing
with.

I've not seen anything to justify a pTLA; where folks I know a
Motorola (one of the larger networks on the planet) and the like
certain DO justify it.

Thank you,
chuck

Quoting John Fraizer (tvo@EnterZone.Net):
> On 20 Oct 2002, Nicolas DEFFAYET wrote:
> > Here a FAQ, no more reply on this list about "pTLA request NDSOFTWARE -
> > review closes 23 October 2002".
> > 
> > NDSoftware pTLA request is fully compliant with RFC2772.
> > http://mailman.isi.edu/pipermail/6bone/2002-October/006364.html
> > 
> > Don't try to find a bug, there is no bugs.
> > If you are jealous, search another victim.
> > 
...
> I don't know about "bugs" in your application but, there are several
> compliance issues, which I have already pointed out in previous emails.
...
> OK.  And how do you suppose that you're going to qualify for an sTLA?
> 
> > 
> > Is Nicolas DEFFAYET is a kid without brain who destroy 6bone ?
> > 
> > I'm Nicolas DEFFAYET, i have 4 years, i got every day to school, and i
> > play with my FisherPrice routers and i destroy all 6bone.
> > 
> 
> I hope you don't mind but, I'm going to use that in my signature line from
> now on.  It's so funny!