[6bone] pTLA request NDSOFTWARE - review closes 23 October 2002

[Weinberger Andreas]

hi there,

as pim wrote:

> In short: I oppose to this request also. Please read on.

i oppose to this request, too.

there is imho no need for a pTLA (someone said private tla,
perhabs the better description ;)) or ndsoftware, they aren't
any kind of an isp nor they have a lot of ipv6 customers.

for playing around i think, the /32 are enough (rir space is
also "only" /32, and lot of isp can live quite good from it...).

if any ix (btw, most ix are v6 only, they use a seperate switch)
needs ip addresses, go to the rir and request a /48 for it like
the others.

also, it looks like that ndsoftware wants to collect a lot of
bgp peers to be "kewl". they dont think about routing instability
or bgp flapping - and the effects to the whole ipv6 network
(both 6bone and "rir").

have a nice day,

bye,
::::
:: andreas 'randy' weinberger
::      networking group
:: ebv elektronik gmbh&co. kg
:: mail: a.weinberger@ebv.com
:: phone: +49 (0)8121 774-508