[6bone] SUNET announcing ALL IPv6 routes

Jørgen Hovland jorgen@hovland.cx
Wed, 14 Aug 2002 22:12:20 +0200


Since SICS have shut down their router now, it might help us to be able to traceback the ASN(s) who are making all the
zombie-routes. There are still a lot of prefixes in the routing table with origin as1654.

For i2001:2F8::/35    there must be one of these three 6939 14277 8002
We know its not 6830, right Roger? And most likely not Edisontel, right Edisontel?

6969 HE.NET
14277 NOKIA
8002 STEALTH

The other route-paths are long.
They all end with STEALTH before they reach SICS.
I dont believe the ones we peer with are generating these routes so I have skipped those (but you never know).

33 DEC.com
10318 LACNIC.net
12199  <- Nonexisting, who is using this?
145 MCI
7580 TRUMPET.com.au
10566 Viagenie
5408 GRNET.gr
2549 LACNIC.net
109 CISCO
5539 SPACE.net
8379 EUROCYBER.net
1275 C&W ecrc.de

Its probably not Viagenie, nor Cisco (god forbid), nor Space, nor MCI, nor Eurocyber?
DEC, LACNIC, GRNET, C&W, TRUMPET and as12199 is left.

As you say John, OS and version if you are announcing ghost-routes please.


   Network          Next Hop            Metric LocPrf Weight Path
* i2001:2F8::/35    3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::5
                                                  100      0 6830 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
*                   2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
* i2001:388::/35    3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::5
                                                  100      0 6830 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
*                   2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
* i2001:388::/32    3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::5
                                                  100      0 6830 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
*                   2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
* i2001:4E0::/32    3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::5
                                                  100      0 6830 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
*                   2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 6939 14277 8002 1654 i
* i2001:6F0::/35    3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::5
                                                  100      0 6830 12337 8319 3561 3748 8002 5609 1275 20834 3274 1654 i
*>                  3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 8379 8319 3561 3748 8002 5609 1275 20834 3274 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 8379 8319 3561 3748 8002 5609 1275 20834 3274 1654 i
*                   2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 12337 8319 3561 3748 8002 5609 1275 20834 3274 1654 i
*> 3FFE:200::/24    2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 237 3748 3786 10566 1930 2200 1916 11537 22 109
5539 8379 1275 8002 1654 i
* i                 3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::5
                                                  100      0 6830 6175 10318 33 5609 6939 4716 2497 4697 2914 1916 11537 22 109 5539
8379 1275 8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 6830 6175 10318 33 5609 6939 4716 2497 4697 2914 1916 11537 22
109 5539 8379 1275 8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 6435 6175 10318 33 5609 6939 4716 2497 4697 2914 1916 11537 22
109 5539 8379 1275 8002 1654 i
*  3FFE:1100::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 237 3748 3786 10566 13193 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 237 3748 3786 10566 13193 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 237 3748 3786 10566 13193 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:1400::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:1A00::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
   Network          Next Hop            Metric LocPrf Weight Path
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:1B00::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:1E00::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:1F00::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:2F00::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:3400::/24   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i
*  3FFE:8060::/28   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::19
                                                           0 15982 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
*                   3FFE:82B0:0:1:1::15
                                                           0 24765 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275
8002 1654 i
   Network          Next Hop            Metric LocPrf Weight Path
*>                  2001:750:E::A                          0 15589 33 10318 12199 145 7580 10566 5408 2549 109 5539 8379 1275 8002
1654 i

-joergen hovland

----- Original Message -----
From: "John Fraizer" <tvo@EnterZone.Net>
To: "Jorgensen, Roger" <RJorgensen@upctechnology.com>
Cc: "'Gert Doering'" <gert@space.net>; "Jørgen Hovland" <jorgen@hovland.cx>; <6bone@mailman.isi.edu>; <staff@sunet.se>
Sent: Wednesday, August 14, 2002 10:08 PM
Subject: RE: [6bone] SUNET announcing ALL IPv6 routes


>
> On Wed, 14 Aug 2002, Jorgensen, Roger wrote:
>
> > Hi,
> >
> > Got some feedback from sunet about this and seems like they've /dev/null'ed
> > the IPv4 IP for their endpoint as a temporarly workaround for now.
> > Thanks for the help SUNET!:)
> >
> >
> > Next issue, now I think we have alot of ghost routes to fight...
> >
> >
> > ---
> > Roger Jorgensen (rjorgensen@upctechnology.com)
>
>
> Cool.  That we can do but, in the process, we need to document what router
> platform/code version the people sending the ghost routes are
> running.  This is a very important operational issue, more important that
> actually getting the original announcements to stop.
>
> If you are an operator who peers with someone that is found to be
> ORIGINATING the ghost routes, please, find out what code they're running
> and let the list know.  This "bug" has bitten us too many times already
> and needs to be squashed.
>
> If we compile a list of "bad code", folks will know to avoid using that
> code and/or peering with folks using that code.
>
> The root problem will never get fixed until we take measures to document
> it.
>
>
>
> ---
> John Fraizer              | High-Security Datacenter Services |
> EnterZone, Inc            | Dedicated circuits 64k - 155M OC3 |
> http://www.enterzone.net/ | Virtual, Dedicated, Colocation    |
>
>