bad routing
Robert J. Rockell
rrockell@sprint.net
Mon, 29 Nov 1999 23:32:21 -0500 (EST)
This will go a long way to improving the stability of the 6bone as a whole
Thank you very much.
p.s. if you still want to run the old report, it will give pTLA's the chance
to pressure downstreams that are leaking. Thanks again!!
Thanks
Rob Rockell
Sprintlink Internet Service Center
Operations Engineering
703-689-6322
1-800-724-3329, PIN 385-8833
Ines|e gnyne qh vagr bz s|e Ino ngg una {e hgr bpu plxyne?
On Mon, 29 Nov 1999, Masaki Hirabaru wrote:
->Hi. Patricio,
->
->>> >MERIT: Woudl it be possible to jog this report to start blaiming the AS who
->>> >is at fault, rather than the pTLA who cannot fix it?
->
->I thought request is reasonable, so I tried to find my time to
->improve our report script. Today, I did it. New report will be
->delivered later today. To do it, the script had to know which AS
->is a backbone (pTLA). The information is retrieved from 6bone db
->but it may be inaccurate or incomplete and there may be a
->delay. (Since our report is not intended to blame someone, so
->please allow this inaccuracy.)
->
->The right most pTLA's AS (or the left most AS if there is no pTLA
->AS) appeared in the path of a poorly aggregated prefix will be
->listed to be a candidate who allows this first. If the pTLA
->allows prefixes within its pTLA, the entry will be listed with
->"*". (Note that even if the pTLA fixes its filter, the same
->route may be appeared through another pTLA in the next report.)
->
->I also modified a part of the report which lists reserved AS
->numbers used in 6bone. This part now lists unknown AS numbers
->that are not registered in 6bone db. (This will result in listing
->reserved AS numbers, too.)
->
->The same modification was applied to unknown prefixes. It now
->lists prefixes not registered in 6bone db.
->
->I hope this helps 6bone hardening.
->Masaki
->IPMA Project
->
->Here is a part of the report generated with data up to now today.
->
->> Subject: 11/29/99 6Bone Routing Report
->> To: 6bone-routing-report@merit.edu
->> From: owner-6bone-routing-report@merit.edu
->>
->> See http://www.merit.edu/ipma for a more detailed report on routing
->> problems and recommendations on ways service providers can limit the
->> spread of invalid routing information.
->> Send comments and questions to ipma-support@merit.edu
->>
->> To unsubscribe from this list, send mail to
->> 6bone-routing-report-request@merit.edu.
->> A hypermail archive is available at
->> http://www.merit.net/mail.archives/html/6bone-routing-report/
->>
->> Also see http://www.caida.org for more information about Internet
->> statistics collection research efforts.
->>
->> ---------------------------------------------
->> This report is for 11/29/99, peering with
->> VIAGENIE (AS10566) CISCO (AS109) IDIR (AS11264) CICNET (AS1225) WIDE (AS2500) SICS (AS2839) MIT-SIPB (AS3) TELEBIT (AS3263) ETRI (AS3559) CERNET (AS4538) 6COM (AS561) MSR-REDMOND (AS5761) UUNET-US (AS704) CAIRN (AS7081) NUS-IRDU (AS761
0) RADIX (AS7680)
->> ---------------------------------------------
->>
->> Size of 6Bone Routing Table:
->> Max = 97, Min = 94, Average = 94
->> 60 pTLAs (in 3ffe::/16), 7 sTLAs (in 2001::/16)
->> 83 Unique Autonomous System (AS) numbers
->>
->> BGP4+ Traffic Summary:
->> Announcements = 200865 Withdraws = 32470 Unique Routes = 109
->>
->> Unknown AS Numbers (not in 6bone registry):
->> Format: AS-Path (Unknown-AS-Number -- Availability)
->> --------------------------------
->> 10566 1930 3243 (3243 -- 100%)
->> 1225 1275 559 8933 1122 (1122 -- 48%)
->> 1225 1849 1103 766 8933 1122 1121 (1122 1121 -- 26%)
->> 3 145 4557 (4557 -- 35%)
->> 3 145 6509 (6509 -- 1%)
->> 561 5408 10566 6509 818 (6509 818 -- 29%)
->>
->> Unknown Prefixes (not in 6bone registry):
->> Format: Prefix path AS-Path (Origin-AS -- Availability)
->> --------------------------------
->> 0000::/0 path 1225 1673 (ANSNET -- 0%)
->> 0000::/0 path 561 5408 1752 3185 786 1103 1849 4697 (NTT-ECL -- -71%)
->> 0200::/1 path 10566 5408 1752 3185 786 1103 1849 4697 (NTT-ECL -- 30%)
->> 1000::/4 path 561 5408 10566 237 1225 1673 (ANSNET -- 8%)
->> 1800::/4 path 1225 1673 (ANSNET -- 0%)
->> 2000::/6 path 109 1251 1930 10566 5408 1752 3185 786 2547 2547 1225 1673 237 7610 3425 2500 (WIDE -- 47%)
->> 2002::/16 path 5761 (MSR-REDMOND -- 100%)
->> 5f0c:bf00::/32 path 7610 3462 3263 (TELEBIT -- 2%)
->> ::35e0/120 path 7610 3462 3263 (TELEBIT -- 2%)
->>
->> Poorly Aggregated Announcements (>24 in 3ffe:0000::/17 or >28 in 3ffe:8000::/17 or >35 in 2001::/16):
->> Format: Prefix path AS-Path (Origin-AS -- Availability)
->> asterisk(*) means the route is within its pTLA
->> --------------------------------
->> SWITCH (AS559) announced 4 route(s)
->> 3ffe:8034:80::/48 path 1225 1275 559 8933 1122 ( -- 48%)
->> 3ffe:1108:800::/40 path 1225 1275 559 8933 3172 (USOT-ECS -- 48%)
->> 3ffe:8038::/34 path 1225 1275 559 8933 (QTPVSIX -- 48%)
->> 3ffe:803c::/34 path 1225 1275 559 8933 3172 (USOT-ECS -- 48%)
->>
->> CICNET (AS1225) announced 4 route(s)
->> * 3ffe:900:1::/48 path 1225 1312 (LORE/VT -- 99%)
->> * 3ffe:900:2::/48 path 1225 3899 (CHICO -- 100%)
->> 3ffe:2900:5::/48 path 1225 1312 (LORE/VT -- 99%)
->> 3ffe:2802::/32 path 1225 1312 (LORE/VT -- 99%)
->>
->> SICS (AS2839) announced 4 route(s)
->> 3ffe:2610:2::/48 path 2839 3274 8432 (TF-INET-DEV -- 100%)
->> 3ffe:2610:5::/48 path 2839 3274 5469 (AHLSTROM -- 100%)
->> 3ffe:1001:60::/48 path 2839 3274 3336 (HTC -- 100%)
->> 3ffe:2620::/32 path 2839 1741 (FUNET/OTOL/VTTMPOLI -- 95%)
->>
->> IPF (AS5409) announced 3 route(s)
->> 3ffe:3001:3::/48 path 109 5409 8731 8251 (CISTRON -- 98%)
->> 3ffe:604:5::/48 path 109 5409 8731 8251 (CISTRON -- 98%)
->> * 3ffe:3400:100::/48 path 109 5409 8731 (SGH-NET -- 98%)
->>
->> MIT-SIPB (AS3) announced 3 route(s)
->> 3ffe:28ff:4::/48 path 3 (MIT-SIPB -- 80%)
->> 3ffe:2801::/32 path 3 145 5050 (PSC-GP -- 80%)
->> 3ffe:2803::/32 path 3 145 4557 ( -- 35%)
->>
->> JOIN (AS1275) announced 2 route(s)
->> 3ffe:2100:1:17::/64 path 1225 1275 (JOIN -- 88%)
->> 3ffe:3400:300::/48 path 1225 1275 5424 (GST/RMACH/FX/CHRIST/LAX/JSB/FIDENTIA-AT/WAECHTER-AT/GEORG-AT/TIVISION-AT/T0-AT/COGIDATA-AT/TCTL-AT/MEDHOST-AT/SWSCHMIEDE-AT/ENEMY-AT/DUNSHIRN-AT/ATNET-AT -- 12%)
->>
->> REDIRIS (AS766) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:8034:c0::/48 path 1225 1849 1103 766 8933 1122 1121 ( -- 26%)
->>
->> VIAGENIE (AS10566) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:400:d0::/47 path 561 5408 10566 6509 818 ( -- 29%)
->>
->> RCCN (AS1930) announced 1 route(s)
->> * 3ffe:3102::/48 path 10566 1930 3243 ( -- 100%)
->>
->> TELEBIT (AS3263) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:2280:4::/48 path 7610 3462 3263 2852 (CESNET -- 2%)
->>
->> BT-LABS (AS1752) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:2101::/48 path 10566 5408 1752 3185 (ULANC -- 99%)
->>
->> REGIO-DE (AS8319) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:400:1c0::/48 path 2839 3274 8319 (REGIO-DE -- 100%)
->>
->> GRNET (AS5408) announced 1 route(s)
->> * 3ffe:2d00:b::/48 path 10566 5408 8617 (AEGEAN -- 99%)
->>
->> SPACENET-DE (AS5539) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:1402:1:1::/64 path 1225 1103 5539 1273 (NAHENET/ECRC -- 20%)
->>
->> ICM-PL (AS8664) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:902::/32 path 1225 8664 (ICM-PL -- 98%)
->>
->> UUNET-US (AS704) announced 1 route(s)
->> 3ffe:1108:1400::/40 path 704 (UUNET-US -- 100%)
->>
->> 6COM (AS561) announced 1 route(s)
->> * 3ffe:1900:9::/48 path 561 11261 (ASCI -- 66%)
->>
->> Prefixes from Different Origin AS:
->> Format: Prefix path AS-Path (Origin-AS -- Availability)
->> --------------------------------
->> BAY (3ffe:1300::/24) path 561 10318 (FIBERTEL -- 59%)
->> BAY (3ffe:1300::/24) path 1225 6175 (SPRINT -- 100%)
->> VIAGENIE (3ffe:b00::/24) path 10566 (VIAGENIE -- 100%)
->> VIAGENIE (3ffe:b00::/24) path 3 145 6509 ( -- 1%)
->>
->> The Top Five Most Active Prefixes (more than 1000 changes):
->> Format: AS-Path (Announce/Withdraw -- Availability)
->> ----------------------------------
->> 1. SICS (3ffe:200::/24) had 31737 BGP+ updates (28 unique aspaths)
->> 2839 (904/0 -- 100%)
->> 7610 3425 293 5609 2839 (49/2 -- 98%)
->> 3 10566 6175 3274 2839 (3904/8 -- 98%)
->> 2500 2500 2500 33 5609 2839 (27/15 -- 70%)
->> 109 33 5609 2839 (3/0 -- 69%)
->> 7081 293 5609 2839 (4540/1627 -- 42%)
->> 10566 6175 3274 2839 (3955/909 -- 29%)
->> 5761 6175 3274 2839 (897/891 -- 29%)
->> 109 1849 5623 2839 (1/0 -- 28%)
->> 561 10318 1849 5623 2839 (5/5 -- 26%)
->> 1225 1275 1835 2839 (995/417 -- 15%)
->> ...Truncated...
->>
->> 2. G6 (3ffe:300::/24) had 16546 BGP+ updates (29 unique aspaths)
->> 10566 1930 559 1717 (4415/60 -- 99%)
->> 2839 1835 1717 (888/0 -- 99%)
->> 3 10566 1930 559 1717 (4397/21 -- 98%)
->> 7081 5409 559 1717 (1173/3 -- 97%)
->> 1225 1275 1717 (948/4 -- 88%)
->> 109 1849 786 1717 (3/0 -- 72%)
->> 7610 3425 293 1275 1717 (49/0 -- 66%)
->> 2500 2500 2500 109 1849 786 1717 (10/10 -- 53%)
->> 7610 1849 786 1717 (3/1 -- 32%)
->> 109 5409 559 1717 (2/0 -- 27%)
->> 561 10318 1849 786 1717 (2/2 -- 26%)
->> ...Truncated...
->>
->> 3. UIO (3ffe:2a00::/24) had 15200 BGP+ updates (68 unique aspaths)
->> 2839 224 (887/0 -- 100%)
->> 7610 3425 293 5609 2839 224 (49/1 -- 98%)
->> 3 10566 6175 3274 2839 224 (2735/1 -- 98%)
->> 2500 2500 2500 33 5609 2839 224 (28/16 -- 70%)
->> 7081 293 5609 2839 224 (2234/0 -- 58%)
->> 109 33 5609 2839 224 (3/0 -- 47%)
->> 7081 6175 3274 2839 224 (234/1 -- 41%)
->> 10566 6175 3274 2839 224 (2772/892 -- 30%)
->> 5761 6175 3274 2839 224 (880/735 -- 30%)
->> 109 1849 5623 2839 224 (2/0 -- 20%)
->> 1225 1275 1835 2839 224 (1002/288 -- 15%)
->> ...Truncated...
->>
->> 4. UNI-C (3ffe:1400::/24) had 15039 BGP+ updates (51 unique aspaths)
->> 2839 1835 (901/0 -- 99%)
->> 7610 3425 293 1275 1835 (46/1 -- 96%)
->> 1225 1275 1835 (782/21 -- 83%)
->> 7081 293 1275 1835 (469/3 -- 78%)
->> 2500 2500 2500 33 3462 3263 1835 (25/15 -- 70%)
->> 3 10566 1930 559 1717 1835 (1658/1 -- 70%)
->> 109 5409 559 1717 1835 (6/0 -- 63%)
->> 561 5609 2839 1835 (5/5 -- 35%)
->> 3 10566 1930 559 1275 1835 (386/0 -- 27%)
->> 7081 5409 559 1717 1835 (1284/3 -- 21%)
->> 109 5409 559 1275 1835 (1/0 -- 20%)
->> ...Truncated...
->>
->> 5. JOIN (3ffe:400::/24) had 8777 BGP+ updates (26 unique aspaths)
->> 4538 1275 (6/1 -- 100%)
->> 2839 1835 1275 (663/0 -- 92%)
->> 1225 1275 (949/0 -- 88%)
->> 7610 3425 293 1275 (49/0 -- 66%)
->> 2500 2500 2500 33 1225 1275 (803/599 -- 61%)
->> 109 4556 1225 1275 (3/0 -- 60%)
->> 10566 5408 559 1275 (422/3 -- 50%)
->> 10566 1930 559 1275 (3356/0 -- 49%)
->> 7081 293 1275 (16/0 -- 47%)
->> 561 5609 1225 1275 (4/3 -- 45%)
->> 3 145 7081 293 1275 (1/0 -- 33%)
->> ...Truncated...
->>
->>
->